Please pardon our dust. We are currently in the midst of launching Collegian Central beta for the summer! Please send any issues to digitalmedia@collegian.com.

Loading

Chemicals are All Natural Too

Opinion | 4 months ago

When was the last time you either read on a label or were told by someone that a product contained something “natural”? It seems as though the terms “all natural,” “no artificial X or Y,” and (arguably the worst) “no chemicals” have become all the rage with people concerned about their health and what they [...]

Chemicals are All Natural Too

Rafael RiveroWhen was the last time you either read on a label or were told by someone that a product contained something “natural”? It seems as though the terms “all natural,” “no artificial X or Y,” and (arguably the worst) “no chemicals” have become all the rage with people concerned about their health and what they eat.

The problem with this idea is that chemicals themselves are completely natural. This is why there is an entire branch of the natural sciences devoted to studying them — it’s called “chemistry”.

In spite of this, the smear campaign against the word “chemical” is so entrenched in society that it has gotten to the point where people actively seek out these products because they genuinely believe that in being more natural or lacking synthetic chemicals, the product is better than everything else.

Chemicals make up everything. From the air we breathe to the water we drink, everything is a chemical.

One clever ruse employing the actual definition of a chemical entails mentioning something like dihydrogen monoxide.

This chemical is actually derived from a highly dangerous and highly reactive hydroxyl radical. This radical has been conclusively proven to alter cell membranes, disrupt neurotransmitters, and even go so far as denaturing proteins (rendering them useless) and mutating DNA, the very fabric of life.

It’s not only the radical that can do this. The components of dihydrogen monoxide itself can be found in things like nitroglycerine (an explosive) and sulfuric acid (a highly caustic acid), among other things.

Sounds quite bad, doesn’t it? Well, the common name for this chemical is actually water. Yep, water. “Di” means two and “mono” means one. Hence: dihydrogen monoxide (H2O).

With every chemical in nature, there’s a caveat. The same that applies to water applies to everything else. It’s true that water and what it’s made of can kill you quite easily. But so can any other naturally occurring chemical.

The one thing that most people don’t understand is that many of the medicines, food additives, and even poisons that they know are made or at least derived from natural sources. The best medicines are usually the latest and greatest plant or fungal extracts. Nature has this odd way of helping things live and also killing mercilessly.

Case in point: foxgloves. This group of plants is extremely poisonous, but a group of chemicals inside of them that were extracted and purified (cardiac glycosides) have been used to treat heart failure and cardiac issues.

Socrates probably wasn’t a big fan of the hemlock variety of plants, since it was used to execute him, yet its chemicals and extracts can be used as a sedative. Much more effective is Oleander, which is so poisonous that even eating honey (organic or not) produced by bees that digested oleander nectar can kill a person. And don’t get me started on arsenic. Talk about all natural!

Just because it was synthesized in a lab doesn’t mean it’s not natural, either. As mentioned before, the extracts from the plant need to be purified. The purification in the lab leads to the creation of the drug or chemical compound necessary. This has been done to get chemicals like aspirin and penicillin out of bark and fungi, respectively.

Great cancer-fighting pharmaceuticals have similar natural beginnings as well. The abridged list includes etoposide (from May Apples), vinblastine and vincristine (from rosy periwinkles), and taxol (from yew leaves). Even pesticides (which are often frowned upon by many) are made from natural chemicals produced by plants to ward off insects.

As soon as we know the chemical in the plant, we can synthesize it ourselves (if it’s easier than extracting). And that’s alright, too. I’ll give you an example. Here’s two chemicals that have the exact same structure … my question is, which one is synthetic and which is natural? C9H8O4 or C9H8O4? Considering the fact that they both look identical at a molecular level, your body doesn’t and can’t know the difference.

“But then why purify it? Keep it natural!” you say. Well, it’s purified because these chemicals occur naturally at such low concentrations that they’re useless. Either that or, unless fixed slightly, they can harm or kill you.

So, next time you hear someone mention the idea of “natural” over anything else, help them understand. They’re just misunderstanding the science.

  • Bill

    chemicals may be from natural sources, but they are isolated, extracted, and consumed through means outside of how nature intended them.

    • EB

      Nature does not intend anything. Why do humans feel it necessary to make everything exactly like us? We personify everything! Atoms, molecules, enzymes, proteins, do not think, act, feel or intend anything. They react to there surroundings based on electrostatics, magnetism, gravity and other physical phenomenon. The only reason reactions take place is because somehow that reaction lowers the overall energy state of the system! What is worse then your “nature intended” comment is people thinking they are the greatest thing in the universe and there has to be something better than humans that created us! Why can’t the awesome reactions that occur (to lower the overall energy of the system) be enough, the fact all species evolved over millions of years, why isn’t that amazing enough? Is it because humans are center centric and can’t really understand anything much different from ourselves? We have problems understanding size scales not similar to our own, that is a fact. Or is it humans have this fear of our own mortality, so we lessen the importance of our environment to make ourselves feel more important? I say finding explanations to these amazing phenomenon that give rise to these natural chemicals (and everything else “natural” is enough of a “reason to it all”, and this crap about how great we are is just that, crap. Maybe the world “wishes” we were extinct as we are “nature’s” biggest mistake (assuming nature is an entity that can make mistakes, could be since it also intends!)

      Also this all natural fad is a fad to make more money for the people selling it. Same as things labeled “pure”. Ask any scientist worth their salt what is meant by pure and be prepared for a long discussion, its a much deeper concept then the Webster version.

      • Richard

        Although I agree with EB that there is no intention in nature or in fact in anything – it is a human construct, Bill does have a point too. Huge quantities of chemicals that are synthesised don’t occur by themselves in nature. Organisms have evolved with the assumption of their continued non-existence. This means that when newly synthesised chemicals are released into ecosystems without previous exposure, problems are likely to occur. Organisms won’t have developed a resistance to these chemicals or evolved to be able to utilise them. This is why pollution of all sorts is such a big issue. When something has been naturally produced, i.e. without the addition of newly synthesised chemicals or traces of herbicides/pesticides it is much more likely that organisms (like us) have the correct molecular equipment to deal with it.

Cost of college tuition out of control

Opinion | 1 day ago

This coming school year we are all in for a surprise with a 9 percent tuition increase which brings the cost of tuition up to $7,494 for the fall and spring semesters of the 2014 school year. Rate increases are a problem seen with all colleges. In the last 13 years, tuition at CU has [...]

The futility of gun-control

Opinion | 1 month ago

“A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”  The Second Amendment is very clear on how guns should be handled. The definition of infringed by Merriam-Webster dictionary is, “Act so as to limit or undermine.” After [...]

Fair Trade Lovin’

Opinion | 1 month ago

Fair Trade is a non-profit organization that represents a brand of products being grown and produced on farms where farmers and workers get paid a fair wage for their labor. Along with fair wage and no child labor, Fair trade promotes sustainable farming in disadvantaged communities by educating producers to improve community development, and producing [...]

You are this paper

Opinion | 1 month ago

It was 10:30 p.m. two Saturdays ago and a couple of roommates had made their usual pit stop at our place before heading out into another wild Fort Collins weekend. No, it was nothing special. Just a bunch of burnt-out college juniors getting ready for one last hurrah before feeling the full weight of finals [...]

Pay attention to club sports

Opinion | 1 month ago

Over the weekend the CSU Women’s Lacrosse Team became national champions, defeating the University of California, Santa Barbara. They didn’t lose a single game, making their championship win the crown jewel in a perfect season. The problem is, not everyone really knows that CSU does have championship teams like the lacrosse teams. Anonymity is a problem that [...]

A study abroad attitude for summer

Opinion | 1 month ago

Summer is a time rife with possibilities. Three long months of freedom from the school year yawn before us, beckoning for us to do something besides watch reality TV. Even if a summer job or a few classes interrupt the blissful orb of summer, there are always those moments of apparent “nothing to do:” that [...]

Reflections of a professional theatre goer

Opinion | 1 month ago

The first play I ever saw was a production of “Cabaret” at the Community College of Aurora when I was 10-years-old. Now, if you are familiar with the musical, you may wonder why a 10-year-old would be at such a production. My friend’s mom was the costume designer for the show and they invited me [...]

Confessions from your Friday Columnist

Opinion | 1 month ago

Before you read this last piece of mine, I have to sincerely thank you, my readers, for putting up with my columns all year long. That being said, there are still some things I need to get off my chest before I graduate and enter the real world, where I’ll be a nameless, faceless and [...]

What is your freedom of speech costing you?

Opinion | 1 month ago

I am a diehard Minnesota Vikings fan. Even though they consistently lose and still refuse to draft a decent quarterback, I will continue to wear my jersey and braids with pride. So let’s just say that I wasn’t particularly surprised when I got word that the Vikings released their punter, Chris Kluwe, out of his [...]

Capitalistic companies should not be our ‘vehicle’ for space travel

Opinion | 1 month ago

Late last month, a Netherlands based organization began accepting applications for sending people to Mars. Exciting right? Well actually, it’s more of a mixed bag. Especially when one considers what the future of humanity has in store for it by allowing capitalistic based interests be our representatives in space exploration. Certainly there is great excitement [...]

Still reading Tony Frank's emails . . . and I've graduated . . . something might be wrong with my summer.